The nuclear monopoly nearing it's end - Avnery writes about Vanunu
GUSH SHALOM - pob 3322, Tel-Aviv 61033 www.gush-shalom.org]
[As former Knesset Member Uri Avnery took part in this week's Knesset
Committee discussion of the Vanunu restrictions, and in this article reveals
some absurd details. He also explains the significance of the sacrifice of
Vanunu, forcing through the nuclear discussion in Israel.]
For Whom the Bells Toll
Hebrew http://zope.gush-shalom.org/home/he/channels/avnery/1114330942 עברית
Uri Avnery, 23.4.05
An Iranian technician called Jalal-a-Din Taheri, who had been working at the
nuclear reactor at Bushehr, managed to defect Europe, where he disclosed the
Ayatollahs' plans for producing nuclear bombs.
Taheri was acclaimed a hero throughout the world. A number of organizations
nominated him for the Nobel Peace Price. President Bush praised his courage.
Ariel Sharon invited him to come and live in Israel, even calling him one of
the Righteous of the Nations. The Ayatollahs denounced him as a traitor,
infidel, Crusader and Zionist.
This is, of course, an entirely fictitious story. But it corresponds exactly
to the story of Mordechai Vanunu, who is considered by almost all Israelis as
a despicable traitor - proving once again that treason, like pornography, is a
matter of geography.
This week I used my privilege as a former Member of the Knesset to attend a
session of the Knesset Committee for "the Constitution, Law and Justice", in
which the Vanunu affair was discussed. In the course of the session, Knesset
members cursed each other in the language of fishmongers (by which I mean no
offence to fishmongers). Two Likud members, Ronie Bar-On (who once served for
several hours as Attorney General before being ignominiously removed) and
Yehiel Hazan shouted that Vanunu had no human rights, since he was not a human
being. It should be mentioned in all fairness that the chairman of the
committee, Michael Eytan, also a Likud member, strongly condemned these
Vanunu, who in 1986 disclosed to a British newspaper some of Israel's nuclear
secrets, was kidnapped soon after by the Mossad, smuggled back to Israel and
put on trial. He served his sentence: 18 years in prison. For most of the time
he was held in total isolation. (He told me that, in order to keep his sanity,
he would read the New Testament in English out loud, over and over again, and
in this way improved his command of this language, which he now insists on
using instead of Hebrew.)
On his release, he was placed under severe restrictions: he is forbidden to go
abroad, forbidden to move inside the country without prior notification of the
authorities, forbidden to speak with foreigners, forbidden to give interviews.
The Supreme Court has upheld these constraints. Vanunu has violated most of
them, and some weeks ago he was indicted for these violations.
The restrictions were initially imposed for one year, which came to an end
this week. The Knesset committee was about to discuss the possibility of their
being extended, but a few hours before the session, the Minister of the
Interior, Ophir Pines (Labor Party) signed an order extending for another year
the prohibition of leaving the country, and the Army Commander of the Home
Front signed an order to extend the other constraints (under Emergency
At the committee meeting, the representative of the Attorney General set out
the government arguments for this extension: (a) Vanunu still "holds in his
head" dangerous secrets, (b) He has a "phenomenal" memory, (c) If given the
opportunity, he will disclose these secrets abroad.
What is the evidence to support this?
(a) In one of the letters he wrote in prison, Vanunu told his correspondent
abroad that he was in possession of many more secrets, which he had not yet
disclosed. He announced his intention of revealing these secrets at the first
(b) Two years before his release - that is to say, 16 years after his work in
the nuclear installation - he drew in his cell, purely from memory, detailed
and amazingly exact blueprints of the production process. These drawings were
found among the more than a thousand documents seized in his cell.
These facts are more than strange. An inmate who sends letters from prison
knows, of course, that they are censored. Vanunu was bound to know that not
only the prison authorities, but the intelligence services, too, would read
them. When he made the blueprints, he certainly knew they would be seized.
All this indicates that he intended to provoke his tormentors and show them
that he was not broken. It is difficult to take the documents seriously, as
the Supreme Court did, eight months ago, when it confirmed the restrictions. A
person who intends to disclose dreadful secrets does not announce this in
advance to the authorities, and does not prepare blueprints for his
Concerning the matter itself:
(a) Does he "hold in his head" secrets that he has not disclosed in the past?
First of all, Vanunu's knowledge concerns processes as they were 18 years ago.
Can such knowledge be useful today? Hard to believe. As Knesset Member Zehava
Galon (Yahad) remarked at the session: "It is terrifying to imagine that
nothing has changed in Israel's nuclear techniques for 19 years!"
Secondly, before the British paper published his disclosures, Vanunu was
cross-questioned for two whole days by one of the world's leading nuclear
scientists. It is hard to believe that after that he still had any undisclosed
Thirdly, it borders on paranoia to think that he was so sophisticated as to
decide, 18 years ago, to "hold in his head" secrets in order to publish them
20 years later.
Fourthly, Vanunu is no scientist. He worked at the reactor as a technician.
Even if he has a "phenomenal" memory, and even if his blueprints are uncannily
exact, it is hard to believe that they have any remaining significance today.
If this is the case, how to explain the renewal of the restrictions?
The Attorney General's representative insisted that their purpose is not to
punish him for things he has done in the past, which would be illegal (since
he has already been tried and served his full sentence), but to prevent new
crimes (the disclosure of further secrets).
I doubt this. One cannot silence Vanunu. The whole world is interested in him,
and the more he is persecuted, the more this interest will grow. Vanunu cannot
be deterred - he is simple undeterrible (to coin a word). Quite the contrary.
Also, it is impossible to prevent him from coming into contact with
(Some months ago, I was sitting in the evening in the garden of the fabulous
American Colony hotel in East Jerusalem, chatting with the British actress
Vanessa Redgrave, a tireless campaigner for Israeli-Palestinian peace.
Suddenly I noticed Vanunu strolling by. I called him over. Vanessa Redgrave
was very interested in his experiences in prison. How can one prevent this
sort of things happening?)
There remains only one explanation: Revenge. Yehiel Horev, the chief of the
Internal Security Division of the Ministry of Defense, cannot forgive Vanunu
for making a mockery of his security arrangements by wandering around the
parts of the installation in which he had no business to be, freely taking
photos in Israel's most secret installation and smuggling them abroad. That is
indeed infuriating. But vengeance, too, must have its limits.
The more so as the Attorney General's man, answering a query from Knesset
Member Etti Livni, admitted that the same arguments voiced now will also be
valid in another year's time, as well as in five and ten years. In other
words, the constraints may be lifelong.
As for my personal opinion about the substance of the matter:
Nuclear weapons are a threat to all of us. It is impossible to prevent
indefinitely the acquisition of nuclear weapons by more countries in the
Middle East - with Iran in the lead. Other categories of Weapons of Mass
Destruction (chemical and biological) do already exist in neighboring
For years, Israel has enjoyed a nuclear monopoly in the region. My friends and
I have warned that this monopoly is temporary, and that we must use the time
to achieve peace. The hubris of our leaders has prevented this.
Now, the aim must be to free the whole region from weapons of mass
destruction, under strict international and mutual inspection, as part of a
comprehensive peace settlement. That is both possible and practical. When
Vanunu rings the bells, he contributes to the public awakening.
His action is also important for another reason: for the first time, he has
drawn the attention of the Israeli public to the real danger inherent in the
old reactor, which is now more than 40 years old. Several former employees
have now sued the government, claiming that they have contracted cancer (and
some have died) because of safety failures. What will happen in the case of a
Chernobyl-like disaster? Or an earthquake, or a missile strike? Who is
thinking about this? Whose responsibility is it? Who oversees those
Vanunu rings the bells to call attention to a real danger. The question is not
whether he is a pleasant person, whether his views are popular or what he
thinks about the State of Israel, after 12 years of solitary confinement. The
question is whether he is doing a good job.
I, for one, believe he is.
Truth against Truth - reconciling opposite views on the history of the
conflict in 101 steps
Hebrew / עברית
An Arabic translation exists and will soon also be available from the Gush
Contacts where to obtain a translation into Dutch and German [and please tell
us about more!] via
Boycott List of Settlement Products (recently updated)
Now also with list of settlements
Hebrew / עברית
Billboard for Israeli peace activist speakers abroad
--you would like to make a speaking tour?
--you need an Israeli speaker for your peace organization?
--your itinerary is final?
Send your ad and find the right contacts
This could also facilitate joint invitations.
Palestinian olive oil, new harvest - contact Hava Keller
!שמן זית איכותי
מיוöר באזור חברון. äמחיר, לשני ליטר - 50 שקלים
(תרומä נוספת תתקבל בברכä)
חווä קלר - 03-5227124
High quality olive oil!
Produced in the Hebron area. Two liters - 50 Sheqels
(additional donations appreciated)
Hava Keller - 03-5227124
Weekly updates from the peacenewsletter The Other Israel (TOI-Billboard):
To get them by email: write to firstname.lastname@example.org (Adam & Beate)
(by registering for the Israeli TOI-Billboard list you will be receiving a
variety of alerts from different groups - complementary to the Gush Shalom
http://www.gush-shalom.org/arabic/index.html (selected articles in Arabic)
http://www.gush-shalom.org/russian/ (Russian site started with flash
\\photos of recent actions
\\the weekly Gush Shalom ad
\\the columns of Uri Avnery
\\Gush Shalom's history & action chronicle
\\position papers & analysis (in "documents")
\\and a lot more
On the Gush Shalom website links for
Articles and documents in German, French and Spanish
In order to receive Gush Shalom's Hebrew-language
press releases mail to:
Archive of email reports:
If you want to support Gush Shalom's activities you can
send a cheque or cash, wrapped well in an extra piece
of paper to:
or ask us for charities in your country which receive
donations on behalf of Gush Shalom
Please, add your email address where to send our
confirmation of receipt. More official receipts at